Despite widespread expert opinion that those with irritable bowel syndrome (IBS) should be screened for celiac disease, whether it is a good idea is not settled. A recent study (RS Choung et al. Clin Gastroenterol Hepatol 2015; 13: 1937-43) showed that celiac disease has a low prevalence in US patients (mean age 61 yrs in this cohort) with IBS.
Here’s an excerpt of a summary of this report from the AGA Blog: “Should all Patients with IBS be Screened for Celiac Disease?”
Rok Seon Choung et al investigated whether subjects with positive results from serologic tests for celiac disease are frequently diagnosed with IBS or other functional gastrointestinal disorders (FGIDs).
They sent self-report bowel disease questionnaires to 7217 residents of Olmsted County, Minnesota, to collect data on symptoms compatible with functional GI disorders, including IBS, collecting data on symptoms compatible with functional GI disorders, including IBS. These symptom data were linked to surveys of undiagnosed celiac disease conducted among more than 47,000 individuals from the same region, based on results of tests for immunoglobulin A tissue transglutaminase and then endomysial antibody.
Among the 3202 subjects who completed the questionnaires and had their serum sample analyzed, 13.6% had IBS and 55.2% had some gastrointestinal symptoms.
The prevalence of celiac disease, based on serologic markers, was 1.0%. However, whereas 3% of patients with celiac disease met the criteria for IBS, 14% of patients without celiac disease met the criteria for IBS.
Abdominal pain, constipation, weight loss, and dyspepsia were the most frequent symptoms reported by subjects who tested positive for celiac disease, but none of the gastrointestinal symptoms or disorders were significantly associated with results of serologic test for celiac disease.
My take: This study along with others show that celiac disease is infrequent in patients with IBS. Since the symptoms of celiac disease overlap with IBS, I doubt this study will dissuade practitioners from screening for celiac despite the low yield.
Also, this fall I posted several blogs on GMOs. An interesting article (from Vox/Grist) on this subject explains how GMOs are a lot like pornography: It’s practically impossible to define “GMOs”